PSA vs. SGC vs. BGS: Which Card Grading Service Is Best?

SGA Grading

May 12, 2025

Grading Strategy

Grading your sports cards can increase value, add protection, and give buyers confidence. But which grading company should you choose? PSA, SGC, and BGS each offer pros, cons, and key differences in pricing, resale, and turnaround. Here’s a complete comparison to help you decide.

1. What Is Card Grading?

Card grading is the process of evaluating a card’s condition (corners, edges, surface, centering) and assigning a numerical grade, typically from 1 to 10. Graded cards are sealed in a tamper-proof slab.

2. Meet the Grading Companies

**PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator):** Most recognized brand with the highest resale value across most modern sports.
**SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Corporation):** Known for their tuxedo slabs, strong with vintage and faster turnaround.
**BGS (Beckett Grading Services):** Popular for thicker slabs and subgrades; historically dominant in the 2000s and with non-sports.

3. Turnaround Time (as of 2025)

**PSA Value Bulk:** 45–60 business days
**SGC Standard:** 15–25 business days
**BGS Economy:** 40–60 business days (inconsistent)
*Note: All times are subject to changes based on volume.*

4. Pricing (per card)

**PSA Bulk (25+ cards):** $19/card
**SGC Standard (no min):** $18/card
**BGS Economy:** $22/card (subgrades cost extra)

5. Slab Appearance & Features

**PSA:** Clean red & white label, slim clear case, QR + Cert# lookup
**SGC:** Black insert (“tuxedo”), bold font, high contrast, scratch-resistant case
**BGS:** Thick slab, optional subgrades for corners, surface, etc. Some older cases yellow over time.

6. Resale Value Comparison

**Modern Chrome RCs:** PSA commands a 20–40% premium over SGC/BGS
**Vintage (pre-1980):** SGC holds strong value and is respected by vintage collectors
**Non-sports (e.g., Pokémon, Marvel):** BGS still used for thick cards, but PSA is gaining ground

7. Pros & Cons Summary

**PSA Pros:** Best resale value, clean slab, global recognition
**PSA Cons:** Slower turnaround, bulk order minimums
**SGC Pros:** Fast, affordable, vintage respect, sharp slab
**SGC Cons:** Slightly lower resale value on modern cards
**BGS Pros:** Subgrades, thick slab, historic appeal for autos/inserts
**BGS Cons:** Higher price, long delays, aging case issues

8. Which Should You Choose?

💰 **Flipping Modern Rookies:** PSA (maximize ROI)
⚾ **Grading Vintage:** SGC (reputation, speed, sharp slab)
🏆 **Autographed or High-End Inserts:** BGS (subgrades + presentation)
🧑‍🎓 **First-Time Graders:** SGC (low risk, fast feedback)

9. Quick Recap of Grading Comparison

Service	Turnaround	Cost/Card	Slab & Features	Resale Strength
PSA	45–60 days	~$19+ bulk	Slim slab, no subgrades, red/white label	Highest resale; PSA 10s fetch premium
SGC	15–25 days	~$18	Tuxedo slab, half-point scale	Strong value for vintage; faster turnaround
BGS	40–60 days	~$22 + subgrades	Thick slab, subgrades detail	Black Label 10s prized; thick, protective slab

Conclusion

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Choose the service that fits your card, your goals, and your timeline. At SGA Trading Cards, we help screen your cards and choose the best grading path for every submission.

Shop SGA

Find your next rookie card, slab, or deal before it’s gone.

Join the Hobby List

Get tips, product drops, and break alerts—just for collectors.

Follow Us in the Hobby

See what we’re ripping, grading, and shipping this week.

Family-owned. Collector-driven.